Mobile App Versus Responsive Website
While going mobile has become inevitable for businesses, the big question remains HOW. Does a business need a mobile website or a native app? The answer to this question is more complicated than most marketers think. To begin with, there is no generic answer that can straighten out the dilemma. The answer is actually based on an extreme balancing act of a company's strategic goals, business needs, industry type, customer requirements, brand awareness and a whole lot of factors that influence business directly and indirectly.
So, before we get to a solution, it's important to understand the functionality and purpose of both, responsive website and mobile app.
What is a Responsive Website?
Responsive website is website that can identify the user's device and intelligently adapt to the device's screen size. A responsive website can be accessed on a laptop, smart phone or a tablet, with the same functionality and features across devices. A responsive website can be great option for companies that use their website majorly for showing company information, a digital brochure of sorts.
Another alternative to a responsive website is mobile web. Mobile web is also a website, but it is designed specifically for mobile or handheld devices. Companies that use mobile web usually fine-tune content for mobile web. The content becomes lesser yet richer. Usually websites that interact and demand customer interaction in one way or the other, say making a sale, or registering for something or making bookings, or any other call for action from the user, choose to mobile web over a responsive website, such that the call for action part is highlighted given the smaller window.
What is a Mobile App?
Mobile app is a dedicated program that can be downloaded on a mobile device. This program then becomes the link between the user and the brand. Since the app resides in the user's mobile device, it becomes easier for the brand to be in constant touch with the user, collect demographics and statistics, build user profiles and engage customers with the brand. For instance if a pizza place has an app that users have downloaded, the app (or the program) can use native functions of the mobile device to track the user's location and accordingly suggest a great dinner deal at a pizza place close to the user's current location.
Which is the best option?
There is no best option. It is a business call based on business needs. The answer of what to choose would depend on various factors as discussed below:
- 1. Brand awareness:
- This is the age of information. And information is the first thing a potential customer would seek, to understand if she wants to be associated with the brand or not. There are some brands that have reached the zenith of awareness. People don't check their websites to find out about them (well almost). How many of us recall logging into a Pepsi website to know about Pepsi. We already know Pepsi. But for a brand that's not as blessed, potential customers would want to find out, research and then take a call. And if the chain of seamless information is broken because your website did not respond to the mobile device the customer's using, you've (in most cases) lost one. Because so many people are using mobile devices and the number is growing exponentially, it's just common sense to have a website that responds to a mobile device. Now whether it should be a responsive website or mobile web, this call would need to be taken by individual businesses since it would largely depend on particular business requirements.
- 2. Customer requirements
- Does your customer use the website to check out information about your company or is there a call for action or some sort of user engagement involved? Because if there is customer engagement involved, then perhaps an app would make sense. For instance retail industry has seen a tremendous boom with retail apps becoming popular amongst customers. So has the gaming industry transformed with the advent of mobile devices and apps.
- 3. Value add
- You've decided to have an app, great. But you need to work out on how does the app provide value to the customer and only then will the app make sense. What's in it for them? Once this question is answered a lot of confusion over having or not having a mobile app, deliverables of the app and purpose of the app, gets straightened out and the mobile strategy falls into place.
Also, since these two are different platforms meant to solve different purposes, there can be no choice between the two. But thanks to marketers who present a biased opinion, you are most likely to get caught in the dilemma. So here's a quick chart for you to understand the two platforms and (maybe) compare the deliverables.
| FEATURE | MOBILE WEB | MOBILE APP |
|---|---|---|
| Accessibility | Mobile Website is accessible by everyone as long as the mobile device has a browser and an internet connection | Mobile app is accessible by those who have downloaded it. Once downloaded, mobile app can be accessed with an internet connection as well |
| Speed | Mobile websites can be slow and shallow as compared to apps | Apps are fast, intriguing and engaging for consumers |
| Changes / Updates | Making changes in the website is relatively easier | Any changes in the app need to go through Google Play Store and The App Store guidelines |
| Cost | Mobile website's cost would vary depending on if you want a separate mobile version or want a new unified website in responsive design | An app's cost would depend on the scope of the app. The more you want your app to perform, the more you'd invest in it |
| Development / Maintenance | If there is a single website across platforms, then it can be maintained with the same code. But if the mobile website is different, it would require up gradation/ separately | An app would need separate maintenance and up gradation |
| User Experience | Mobile websites can be good if the purpose of the website is information | Apps are perfect when customer's interaction and automation is required, e.g. Retail, ecommerce, employee interaction etc. |
| Loyalty Rewards | A website, be it mobile website or of the web, it cannot track repeat visitors and keep track of their usage as smartly as an app can do | Apps are downloaded on the user's mobile device. It means app can interact with the user, provide loyalty incentives and even send gentle reminders to dormant customers |
| Check Out | The check out process for online buying can be a tedious affair | App stores important information (of course securely) and makes the whole buying process a breeze. |
| Personalized | A website experience is for masses, it cannot be personalized | Apps take personalization to a whole new level; customers see the products they like, get discounts when they want, get alerts relevant to them and get an individualistic experience rather than one designed for masses |
| SEO | A mobile website would assist SEO initiatives by adding searchable content on the web | Apps are not directly beneficial for SEO initiatives, but again if a user has already downloaded the app, web search would not make any difference |
| Customer Data | Website does not help gathering data about visitors except counting numbers on a superficial level | Apps become a part of the consumer's mobile hence can gather data for personal profiling, social profiling and accordingly personalization |
| Social Media | A website can enable limited sharing on social media | Apps enable sharing and connecting on social media. Moreover apps can have a viral effect if the app provides a service/feature that appeals to people |
If there are still any questions that remain unanswered or any concern that needs to be addressed regarding your mobile strategy, reach us on 415-504-1516, and we'd be happy to help.






